全ての報告
ノイシュヴァンシュタイン城(Castle of Mad King Ludwig)の報告
#173212: "The game would let me place a room that partially overlapped with another room"
どうしましたか?以下から選んでください
ルール: ゲームのルールが正しく実装されていない
詳細
-
• BGAで正しく実装されていないルールはどの部分ですか?
Should not be able to place a room on top of another room
-
• ルールの間違いはゲームのリプレイで確認できますか?そうであれば、行動番号は何番ですか?
No, changed the placement, but took a screenshot.
imgur.com/a/34ABasr • あなたのブラウザは何ですか?
Google Chrome v137
報告履歴
2025年Jun19日 14:19 • MaxMinus • バグは未だ開発者によって再現できていません:
The octagonal room in the screenshot is on topOf the square room in its lower right corner
2025年Jul2日 0:27 • HeirOfIsildur11 • バグは開発者に確認されました:
This happened to me as well - I was able to place a Utility Room overlapping my Moat
imgur.com/a/SIGoqOM
Table 691928863
imgur.com/a/SIGoqOM
Table 691928863
2025年Jul6日 20:37 • wolmot • バグは開発者に確認されました:
Experienced a pretty bad case in game #696963582, check at move #24
See also imgur.com/a/65MB5KJ
2 sleeping rooms of size 300, and I was allowed to place them almost completely overlapping.
See also imgur.com/a/65MB5KJ
2 sleeping rooms of size 300, and I was allowed to place them almost completely overlapping.
2025年Jul31日 22:29 • BanBan • バグは開発者に確認されました:
Partially fixed:
There is still some issue with rooms that are concave (rooms with a size of 300 and moats tiles)
There is still some issue with rooms that are concave (rooms with a size of 300 and moats tiles)
2025年Aug22日 0:43 • Kaladry • バグは開発者に確認されました:
I encountered this at table 716353392. My storage room overlaps with another storage room (I am orange).
2025年Aug23日 21:51 • Tamloo • バグは開発者に確認されました:
I also had a similar issue with the Kitchen and Sauna imgur.com/a/AIiA5fS
Game 719442747 move 67 I think
Game 719442747 move 67 I think
2025年Sep4日 10:22 • WildPenguin82 • バグは開発者に確認されました:
It's not only concave rooms - a small but real consideration that is easy to miss if the foyer. It's doorways are slightly larger than normal rooms (or corridors), i.e. their corners don't quite match on the (imaginary) grid. This also means the slanted corners - the parts with no doorways - are slightly shorter and further away from the center of the piece.
Players are currently able to put large 600 rooms so that the 45° part is against the foyer. This should not be possible since the pieces actually overlap (I've tested this on the real tabletop game). The foyer is larger probably for this exact reason (or, corners "cut" for esthetic reasons), but should be considered a 400 size room for all practical purposes (no room can fit on the cutaway part of the corner, compared to a square room of similar size).
For reference, table 718564545 has such a move, Vestibule is inserted in a position not allowed by the rules at move 57.
Players are currently able to put large 600 rooms so that the 45° part is against the foyer. This should not be possible since the pieces actually overlap (I've tested this on the real tabletop game). The foyer is larger probably for this exact reason (or, corners "cut" for esthetic reasons), but should be considered a 400 size room for all practical purposes (no room can fit on the cutaway part of the corner, compared to a square room of similar size).
For reference, table 718564545 has such a move, Vestibule is inserted in a position not allowed by the rules at move 57.
2025年Sep4日 10:45 • WildPenguin82 • バグは開発者に確認されました:
Correction: a *large round room* of size 500 can use the cutaway correctly, so the foyer is not quite practically equal to a size 400 square room.
2025年Sep4日 10:50 • WildPenguin82 • バグは開発者に確認されました:
Another correction, since I seem to be hallucinating ;-). I though somehow size 400 is 3x3 while it is actually 4x4. So disregard that part of the comments above. The foyer can only be compared to a regular 90° corner - and in that regard, only piece which could fit is the large round room. No other 45° cutoffs (of size 600 rooms) or small round rooms (size 150).
2025年Sep4日 11:05 • WildPenguin82 • バグは開発者に確認されました:
For sake of completing the discussion about the foyer (and getting it right once if any fixes are made), a tower (325) piece corner is also probably also meant to fit at the foyer corner. I don't have the real expansion pieces so I can not check, but the curve has probably not started, and if there is any, it is so minuscule that it is probably next to noticeable. The intention in that case is their corners could occupy the same grid square. If someone has the expansion or better knowledge, please comment ;-).
(I haven't checked if the digital version here allows that placement, as I haven't had a chance. But please don't make a check "allow everything but small round and 600 rooms", as that would be incorrect).
(I haven't checked if the digital version here allows that placement, as I haven't had a chance. But please don't make a check "allow everything but small round and 600 rooms", as that would be incorrect).
2025年Sep4日 11:08 • BanBan • バグは開発者に確認されました:
@WildPenguin82, could you please add a screenshot for each of your different cases ?
It will be really helpful for fixing it, thanks a lot!
It will be really helpful for fixing it, thanks a lot!
2025年Sep5日 4:27 • drape • バグは開発者に確認されました:
Here's another game where this happened: boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/250903-0908/?table=725254856&player=84554620&comments=84554620;
imgur.com/a/b9JSQe7
imgur.com/a/b9JSQe7
2025年Sep6日 13:31 • WildPenguin82 • バグは開発者に確認されました:
For the size 600 + Foyer:
imgur.com/a/sn8z1J5
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/250819-1100/?table=718564545&player=86283401&comments=93649312;
For the other cases, I haven't seen them in-game since as such situations are rare, but possible. It is possible the game already handles them correctly, but I just decided to mention them since there already seem to be some oversights in the code that I would make sense to check these cases when making the fix. It is also possible to make a fix in-code and introduce new ones.
It's just FYI; in case I encounter these situations I will surely test and add a screenshot.
imgur.com/a/sn8z1J5
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/250819-1100/?table=718564545&player=86283401&comments=93649312;
For the other cases, I haven't seen them in-game since as such situations are rare, but possible. It is possible the game already handles them correctly, but I just decided to mention them since there already seem to be some oversights in the code that I would make sense to check these cases when making the fix. It is also possible to make a fix in-code and introduce new ones.
It's just FYI; in case I encounter these situations I will surely test and add a screenshot.
2025年Sep6日 13:41 • WildPenguin82 • バグは開発者に確認されました:
I've added an image highlighting the differences of the Foyer geometry which is also the reason 600 corners don't fit against Foyer. It is curious why they made the foyer this way. Probably to make it "slightly easier" than a 3x3 square to work with but not too much.
imgur.com/a/comkl-overlapping-foyer-size-600-room-sn8z1J5
imgur.com/a/comkl-overlapping-foyer-size-600-room-sn8z1J5
報告に書き加える
このバグを再現するため、またはあなたの提案を理解するために、ここに関連性があると思われるものを追加してください:
- 他のテーブルID/行動ID
- F5キー(ページの再読込)で問題は解決されましたか?
- 問題は何回も起こりましたか?毎回 起こりますか?ランダムに起きますか?
- もしこのバグのスクリーンショットがあれば(素晴らしい!)、Imgur.com等を使ってアップロードし、リンクをコピー&ペーストしてください。
