全ての報告
フリップ7(Flip 7)の報告
#164969: "Rules check: order of resolution when multiple Flip Three / Freeze cards revealed on Flip Three"
どういった内容ですか?
どうしましたか?以下から選んでください
ルール: ゲームのルールが正しく実装されていない
詳細
• BGAで正しく実装されていないルールはどの部分ですか?
The order of resolution when multiple Flip Three and Freeze cards are revealed from a single Flip Three resolution.
1. Player A draws and gives a Flip Three to Player B.
2. B draws in order: a 4 (does not pair), then a Freeze, then a Flip Three.
3. B had to play their Flip Three first, then their Freeze.
Current discussion in BGG forum: boardgamegeek.com/thread/3494523/• ルールの間違いはゲームのリプレイで確認できますか?そうであれば、行動番号は何番ですか?
Moves #40-#42 of Table #654254774
See snapshots: imgur.com/a/Htvns2X• あなたのブラウザは何ですか?
Google Chrome v135
報告履歴
2025年 4月13日 1:00 •
aba_dab_o • バグは未だ開発者によって再現できていません:
2025年 4月29日 7:33 • Update to the rules through the BGG forum: boardgamegeek.com/thread/3494523/article/46016275#46016275
Flip 3:
1) Flip three cards, one at a time. Stop if you Bust or Flip 7. (If you Flip 7, the round ends immediately for all players. Go straight to scoring.)
2) Keep a Second Chance if you don't already have one. If you do already have one, immediately assign the new one to another player. (During a Flip 3 you are allowed to use a Second Chance card in your possession -- whether newly drawn or previously owned -- to neutralize a number card that would otherwise bust you.)
3) Temporarily set aside any Flip 3's or Freezes. Discard them if you subsequently Bust or Flip 7.
4) After flipping all three required cards (without Busting or Flipping 7), hand out all set aside cards **in the order they were flipped** and to whomever you choose. (You *may* give multiple cards to the same player or to different players at your discretion. If you are the only active player remaining, then you must give all set aside cards to yourself.)
5) The player(s) will then resolve those action cards in the order in which you handed them out. (If a single player receives, first, a Freeze, and second, a Flip 3, then after Freezing, that player discards the Flip 3.)
6) After the original Flip 3 and any other subsequent Flip 3 and Freeze cards are all resolved, the Dealer then moves along to the next active player clockwise from the player who got dealt the original Flip 3 by the Dealer, and asks that next player if they wish to "Hit or Stay."
In Flip 7 game #654254774:
- Move #40: aba_dab_o resolves his received Flip Three (from darlinglizzie) by drawing a 4 (no bust / Flip 7), then a Freeze, then a Flip Three.
- Move #41: aba was forced to hand out the Flip Three first (violates rule 4, out of order) and that Flip Three was immediately resolved without handing out the Freeze (violates rule 4, not all action cards drawn from Flip Three were handed out).
What should have happened:
- aba_dab_o resolves his received Flip Three (from darlinglizzie) by drawing a 4 (no bust / Flip 7), then a Freeze, then a Flip Three.
- aba hands the Freeze to a player.
- aba hands the Flip Three to a player.
- The player who received the Freeze is now resolved: freezes and out of round.
- The player who received the Flip Three is now resolved: draws three, follows Flip Three rules.
- If more Flip Three / Freeze cards were drawn from Flip Three, again resolve in order they were drawn and received.
- After all resolutions, next active player clockwise from darlinglizzie takes their turn.
Update to the rules through the BGG forum: boardgamegeek.com/thread/3494523/article/46016275#46016275
Flip 3:
1) Flip three cards, one at a time. Stop if you Bust or Flip 7. (If you Flip 7, the round ends immediately for all players. Go straight to scoring.)
2) Keep a Second Chance if you don't already have one. If you do already have one, immediately assign the new one to another player. (During a Flip 3 you are allowed to use a Second Chance card in your possession -- whether newly drawn or previously owned -- to neutralize a number card that would otherwise bust you.)
3) Temporarily set aside any Flip 3's or Freezes. Discard them if you subsequently Bust or Flip 7.
4) After flipping all three required cards (without Busting or Flipping 7), hand out all set aside cards **in the order they were flipped** and to whomever you choose. (You *may* give multiple cards to the same player or to different players at your discretion. If you are the only active player remaining, then you must give all set aside cards to yourself.)
5) The player(s) will then resolve those action cards in the order in which you handed them out. (If a single player receives, first, a Freeze, and second, a Flip 3, then after Freezing, that player discards the Flip 3.)
6) After the original Flip 3 and any other subsequent Flip 3 and Freeze cards are all resolved, the Dealer then moves along to the next active player clockwise from the player who got dealt the original Flip 3 by the Dealer, and asks that next player if they wish to "Hit or Stay."
In Flip 7 game #654254774:
- Move #40: aba_dab_o resolves his received Flip Three (from darlinglizzie) by drawing a 4 (no bust / Flip 7), then a Freeze, then a Flip Three.
- Move #41: aba was forced to hand out the Flip Three first (violates rule 4, out of order) and that Flip Three was immediately resolved without handing out the Freeze (violates rule 4, not all action cards drawn from Flip Three were handed out).
What should have happened:
- aba_dab_o resolves his received Flip Three (from darlinglizzie) by drawing a 4 (no bust / Flip 7), then a Freeze, then a Flip Three.
- aba hands the Freeze to a player.
- aba hands the Flip Three to a player.
- The player who received the Freeze is now resolved: freezes and out of round.
- The player who received the Flip Three is now resolved: draws three, follows Flip Three rules.
- If more Flip Three / Freeze cards were drawn from Flip Three, again resolve in order they were drawn and received.
- After all resolutions, next active player clockwise from darlinglizzie takes their turn.
Update to the rules through the BGG forum: boardgamegeek.com/thread/3494523/article/46016275#46016275
kelby • バグは未だ開発者によって再現できていません:
2025年 6月 8日 21:44 • Same issue occurred to me on table #685008509:
Move #108 I drew a flip three which I was forced to use on myself, and drew a freeze, flip three, and 12 in that order.
Move #109 I was forced to use the flip three even though it was drawn after the freeze.
Move #108 I drew a flip three which I was forced to use on myself, and drew a freeze, flip three, and 12 in that order.
Move #109 I was forced to use the flip three even though it was drawn after the freeze.
Zentor • バグは未だ開発者によって再現できていません:
2025年 6月15日 14:33 • Happened in this game. But also had a 4th card flipped on a Flip 3 card. The 4th card was drawn after the 3rd card knocked the player out. So looks like 2 bugs with the Flip 3 card. First for forced to play before Freeze, and second for cause 4 cards to be flipped.
Table #688097158
Move #16 / 17
Table #688097158
Move #16 / 17
Armand1981 • バグは未だ開発者によって再現できていません:
2025年 6月23日 14:12 • Happened during game (#Table #691772616)
Flip Three gave me 2 cards Bonus when around 200 points.
Game is not clear about the card to be given first, versus second one.
It was not the highlighted card or the 1st one drawn..
==> Give indication to the player about which card (with "Card Name") has to be given and not only "Bonus Card"
Flip Three gave me 2 cards Bonus when around 200 points.
Game is not clear about the card to be given first, versus second one.
It was not the highlighted card or the 1st one drawn..
==> Give indication to the player about which card (with "Card Name") has to be given and not only "Bonus Card"
cigma • バグは未だ開発者によって再現できていません:
2025年 6月29日 11:04 • Same with my game table 694366785, starting move 69. The second Flip 3 turn started before my Flip 3 turn (including Freeze) was fully resolved.
And I second the suggestion of Armand1981: Give indication to the player about which card (with "Card Name") has to be given and not only "Bonus Card".
And I second the suggestion of Armand1981: Give indication to the player about which card (with "Card Name") has to be given and not only "Bonus Card".
報告に書き加える
このバグを再現するため、またはあなたの提案を理解するために、ここに関連性があると思われるものを追加してください:
- 他のテーブルID/行動ID
- F5キー(ページの再読込)で問題は解決されましたか?
- 問題は何回も起こりましたか?毎回 起こりますか?ランダムに起きますか?
- もしこのバグのスクリーンショットがあれば(素晴らしい!)、Imgur.com等を使ってアップロードし、リンクをコピー&ペーストしてください。